58: Is this a common way of measuring changes in size? Looking strictly at mean body size seems simplistic – but a citation would convince me this is a common practice
Equations 1- 12: I find it confusing to reuse mu, eta, and σ throughout the three different modeling approaches and would prefer to see a unique letter applied for each of the three models to improve clarity. I did have some more substantial questions on the CPUE section, which I'll try to put together here. It seems that CPUE is always lower for the heated population. Could the unexpected increased size observed in heated adults be due to a tradeoff between slower growth due to temperature but higher growth due to a release from density dependence? I think the authors suggest this might be the case, but it would be helpful to state it more explicitly.