Bushfires, climate change link a 'philosophical debate': NSW Education Minister

  • 📰 smh
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 58 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 27%
  • Publisher: 80%

Australia Australia Headlines News

Australia Australia Latest News,Australia Australia Headlines

NSW Education Minister Sarah Mitchell has described the link between climate change and bushfires burning throughout the state as a 'philosophical debate' | LisaVisentin

NSW Education Minister Sarah Mitchell has described the link between climate change and bushfires burning throughout the state as a "philosophical debate".

In comments which placed her at odds with the state's Environment Minister, Ms Mitchell said the government's "focus for the immediate period of time" should be supporting communities affected by the bushfires and drought rather than debating the causes of those events. NSW Education Minister Sarah Mitchell says the government's focus should be on helping communities affected by the bushfires and drought rather than debate the causes of those events."At the moment, the discussion isn't around what we should be talking about in terms of climate change, we should be focusing on supporting those communities," Ms Mitchell said in an interview with ABC radio.

Ms Mitchell said she believed in climate change, adding that "it is important that we, as a society, act in relation to these matters."But I also think we need to deal with the immediate issues before us. We've got communities that are struggling." Asked about the link between climate change and bushfires, Ms Mitchell said it was a "philosophical debate about what's caused these bushfires and drought".

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

LisaVisentin Yeah... and then there is this:

LisaVisentin And this is the Education Minister! Not philosophical, not religious. It's not a question of belief. It is science.

LisaVisentin LisaVisentin Not very 'philosophical' when you're caught in a bushfire that's burning out of control because global warming has completely dried out the land & water to put out the fires is scarce. That's all the flamming knowledge & reality you need. auspol climatedeniers

LisaVisentin This is past being idiotic; it's dangerous. NSW Education Minister still questioning the link between climate change and bushfires? What next - evolution is a lie, the world is flat, burn the books? Where do people like that get to make decisions? Religious Fascism gone mad.

LisaVisentin How long after tackling climate change is the fire risk lowered?

LisaVisentin Perhaps when the doctor tells her her child’s appendix needs to be removed immediately, she can take the time to have a ‘philosophical debate’.

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin And this is proof positive that the kids have been deliberately dumbed down,a halfwit at the top,teachers with Atars of 40,a moronic curriculum that prepares them for the 1890s and a government run and influenced by fish and chip shop owners or weirdo middle eastern religions

Newwayofdoing LisaVisentin What rubbish. Has nothing to do with philosophy, it has to do with people committing crimes, who need to be PUNISHED.

LisaVisentin What's philosophical about it Do they ever studied science

LisaVisentin yep in her delusional mind ... everything is philosophical!

LisaVisentin And she is minister for education...her degree from UNSW was in politics... says a lot

LisaVisentin A debate she has clearly already lost.

LisaVisentin Are our so called leaders so devoid of capacity that they cannot address the needs caused by the fires (are they?) and the cause of the fires? ClimateCrisis. I would have thought that the 2 are inseparable. CauseAndEffect

LisaVisentin This woman is a greater danger to our society than every criminal we have locked away.

LisaVisentin We should be paying her peanuts.

LisaVisentin Is this why our results are falling ?

LisaVisentin Philosophy is taking ideas and debate to a higher level; to help us understand things more deeply and tease out why something is that way. To challenge the link between climate change and our bush fire situation does not do this, it is just ignorant... not philosophical.

LisaVisentin Lol

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin Unfit for office.

LisaVisentin Good grief

LisaVisentin Philosophical 🤔 Um no. Actual.

LisaVisentin She is stupid. That's a fact, not an insult.

LisaVisentin To Science or not to Science. That is the (most idiotic) question. Shall we pick and choose other aspects of science too? 🤔

LisaVisentin She has the face of a nong.

LisaVisentin What are Sarah’s vested interests?

LisaVisentin Is the link between an Australiam curriculum and mandatory NAPLAN testing and falling global test scores a philosophical debate as well?

LisaVisentin Here's a link for her, when the LNP government is in charge the students get dumber

LisaVisentin How can she be in charge of our children’s education? How is this possible?

LisaVisentin She never studied science in a state school, did she?

LisaVisentin OMG!

LisaVisentin If I said this kind of irresponsible and outrageously misleading rubbish in the media I’d be sacked immediately

LisaVisentin Well I find myself philosophically opposed to misinformation. I have 2 grandsons in Sydney. Hope she’s not too involved in decisions about their education.

LisaVisentin It’s true. And we Australian’s hate philosophy. We want jobs jobs jobs!!!

LisaVisentin Education Minister you must know ....there is no debate, philosophical or otherwise. Humans are escalating Climate Change rapidly because of fossil fuels and a myriad of slightly less damaging practices that we've all come to rely on. Facts matter. It's Science, pay attention.

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin We’re now living in 1984.

LisaVisentin Politician: Hello climate scientist. Would you like to engage in a philosophical debate on climate change? Climate scientist: Politician: Well, it’s an interesting belief system to think that climate change is real. Climate scientist: Enjoy the apocalypse.

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin To be fair, she is an idiot 😬

LisaVisentin The science doesn’t care what she believes.

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin Is there a rule somewhere saying only the dumbest need apply to be pollies? Disgrace after disgrace spouting nonsense. Resign now EcoTerrorists BoottheBastards ClimateEmergency

LisaVisentin Minister so blind to science , she doesn’t add up.

LisaVisentin She needs to get back to school.

davidbewart LisaVisentin Seriously? How did this 'philosophical' woman get into parliament let alone given education portfolio? Why aren't we told before we vote that politician only need a double digit IQ to qualify for pre-selection?

LisaVisentin Oh Sarah... you’re in need of some urgent educating!!! The science is clear... climate change is REAL. No debate required.

1petermartin LisaVisentin Another LNP dunce, but this one's Education Minister! The correlation is not philosophical but statistical.

LisaVisentin Large bushfires are evidence for climate change just like large snowstorms evidence against it. Weather isn't climate. Outliers aren't trends. You're all as bad as each other.

JonDeeOz LisaVisentin Then she’s about as clever as

LisaVisentin Not when your home goes up in flames!

LisaVisentin There is no choice.

LisaVisentin The NSW Education Minister needs to get herself some learning

LisaVisentin It’s no wonder school education standards are slipping when the minister herself doesn’t understand science

LisaVisentin Revert to Malcolm Turnbull comments on qanda Sarah Mitchell nuts

LisaVisentin Ffs

LisaVisentin Oh god

LisaVisentin I didn't know the climate was a philosophical thing.I thought it was reality

LisaVisentin OK then the so the NSW Education Minister thinks Climate Change is a philosophical debate. Mixing up science with philosophy . Perhaps she is a creationist. Where do they get LNP from. Shallow end of gene pool.

LisaVisentin When will the arraignment start for those in charge of no fire hazard reduction policies in national parks?

LisaVisentin Isn’t ex ABC political editor Brigid Glanville her adviser?

LisaVisentin God help us.

LisaVisentin Says something about the consistency of the LNP party selection process ...

LisaVisentin Which it is.

LisaVisentin Some Fieries having a philosophical debate after another long day, where they want to be, doing what they love. 'Who needs beer and surfboards when you can do this' said no-one.

LisaVisentin What a toad ... following the party line because she wants to be 'accepted'.

LisaVisentin Science has no room for ignorance. AirEmergency

LisaVisentin Does she actually understand the idea of a philosophical debate and scientific research?

LisaVisentin Another politician opens their mouth and their blatant stupidity simply falls out

LisaVisentin Sarah Mitchell is a prime example of why every politician needs to hold a minimum of a Bachelor's degree in their respective portfolios. Thick as a brick.

LisaVisentin Yes can definitely see why she's Education minister...NOT

LisaVisentin Holy fcuk - and she is education minister

LisaVisentin So when it happens next year we might have a chance of not having hundreds of homes destroyed? Just remember next year is a few weeks off. As education minister, she should stick to debating education topics like Mathematics

LisaVisentin This is why the schools suck

LisaVisentin Some people never made it out of Plato’s cave perhaps.

LisaVisentin Sorry, but she doesn’t look like she could participate in any debate, philosophical, or not.

LisaVisentin A science denying buffoon as education minister, awesome.

LisaVisentin Increased bushfires indicate Australia is getting greener with more fast growing bushes due to climate change, which is a blessing, not a curse.

LisaVisentin De Edyoukayshen Minasta nose her stuff

LisaVisentin 🙀😳😳😳

LisaVisentin Someone wants to keep their job under a liberal government. 🤔🤔

LisaVisentin Does that mean that the mass extinction, the ice caps melting, the temps rising, bushfire damages getting more extreme, heat wave deaths, bigger longer and more natural disasters are just philosophical matters?

LisaVisentin How the fuck is she affiliated at all with Education? 🧐

LisaVisentin Wonder why our academic levels are so low. Jesus Mary and Joseph. Ffs. Wow. Are you shitting me You cannot be serious.

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin Yeah right! It will be climate change only when their own homes and family burn!!!

LisaVisentin It’s not a philosophical debate , it’s called a policy.

LisaVisentin Obviously this person went to school ,but kept walking past the front gate every day.

LisaVisentin Is she saying that if a tree is on fire in a forest and no one is around to see it , does it really burn ? Who is this FuckWit.

LisaVisentin How do the victims feel - philosophically? How do the volunteers feel- Philosophically? How do the fire experts feel- philosophically? Perhaps the Minister could take her philosophical self off to the bin.. and stay there!!

LisaVisentin Gee just when you herd everything someone proves you wrong 😂 Does she really mean ideology 🤔 i wonder

LisaVisentin What an absolute fool

LisaVisentin FFS when is the revolution?

LisaVisentin It’s absurd that Nats politician Sarah Mitchell is even education minister when, at best, Mitchell has only very ordinary qualifications in politics. But like most things National Party, never let incompetence stand in the way of jobs for the boys & the girls ClimateChange

LisaVisentin How does one define stupidity? Is Sarah Mitchell stupid? Why does Sarah make stupid comments even though she knows they will produce negative outcomes? Let’s have a philosophical debate on the uselessness (or otherwise) of Sarah Mitchell.

LisaVisentin And we wonder why we have fallen so far behind in in the world’s education rankings..! berejiklianboneheads

LisaVisentin auspol ‘I don’t know the scientific explanation, but fire made it bad.’ ClimateEmergency

LisaVisentin ‘Education’ Minister. Educating people that climate change isn’t real* because of religious philosophies. (*climate change is real)

davidbewart LisaVisentin Education minister does not understand the meaning of philosophical

LisaVisentin Education Minister? In a conservative Gov't? Seems about right. They do put the least qualified into these sorts of portfolios.

LisaVisentin Oh boy, there’s a lot to unpack here and it all stinks..

LisaVisentin Now I understand why OZ schools ranked so low

LisaVisentin Another idiot gets into politics.

LisaVisentin GladysB JodiMcKayMP Surely you cannot support an education minister with this lack of understanding on the causes and effects of climate change. The science is in. The science is real. Fact.

LisaVisentin Where do they find these morons?

LisaVisentin Well that'll get your name out there..

LisaVisentin 97% of Climate Scientists would not agree. Why is this a debate?Are majority of Liberal Parliamentarians low in IQ?

LisaVisentin And she's in charge of Education! But doesn't look at facts. Right! Another one. How come this country breeds some many of them? The science is settled in Europe. US is a nut case. Why do we have to copy the US?

davidbewart LisaVisentin No need for a 'philosophical debate' to work out that the minister is talking through her hat and that thinks what she has to say is newsworthy.

LisaVisentin Education minister

LisaVisentin Is Matt Kean and her from the same government?

LisaVisentin Lucky you corrected yourself smitchellmlc It wouldn’t have been a good look for an education minister.

LisaVisentin Do not repeat thought bubbles as headlines unless you want to frame the debate on their terms. FreePress

LisaVisentin Sun-kissed land that can turn sustainable non-fossil fuel economy overnight!! After having a bumper lottery of jumbo island brimming with resources & decimated the oldest surviving human societies; callous complacency shall live on being habitually backward, racist & misogynist!!

LisaVisentin Our country is on fire, Sarah.

LisaVisentin Ok, that’s a relief, I was worried about all those real victims of these bushfires, to know they are only philosophical victims as such.

davidbewart LisaVisentin The climatechange deniers cannot bring themselves to accept what they are witnessing in australia is due to the changing climate caused by anthropogenic activity That means burning coal Ms Visentin

LisaVisentin Another crook!

LisaVisentin Premier Gladys Klinger may gave to settle a dispute between the Environment and Education Ministers. Wonder if the decision will be based on facts (science) or fiction? Wonder if she even knows the difference. Look out Matt Kean!!

LisaVisentin Can I have her job? Actually any ministers job would do... Even my cat knows better

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin Oh, sounds like the mystery of why our kids are years behind the rest of the world has just been solved.

LisaVisentin MinisterInDenial needs some education. Climate Science is based on evidence & fact. Evidence & fact cannot be debated. Here is my piece of Philosophy: Climate Deniers must be removed from government. They are anchors holding back the progress that is needed to ReduceEmissions

LisaVisentin And she’s the education minister? No wonder standards are slipping.

LisaVisentin The link is a result of physics. What you choose to do about that is a moral and philosophical debate.

LisaVisentin Memo to NSW Education Minister Sarah Mitchell

LisaVisentin This person I suppose is in charge of lifting NSW education standards. Good luck with that 🤬

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin She should go back to school and learn some basic science

LisaVisentin They should take that portfolio away.. What hope for lifting the standards of our education with a dimwit like that in control. Speak to your Minister for Environment, Sarah. There is an idea

LisaVisentin No it is not a debate but govt will be blaming everybody else for their own neglect & arrogance

LisaVisentin It's not philosophical. There's a demonstrable scientific link. Anyone in govt who suggests otherwise is endangering us all. At this juncture anyone who refuses to take action against climate change is committing grave crimes against humanity

LisaVisentin You are not fit to be an education minister.

LisaVisentin She needs to fuck right off

LisaVisentin And she’s the education minister...interesting.

LisaVisentin Science.

LisaVisentin That’s why she’s education minister.

LisaVisentin Just more “not-the-right-time”-isms...

bsadams25 LisaVisentin she's missing a link between her brain and mouth... and that's not philosophical but fact

LisaVisentin It’s SCIENCE for heaven’s sake.

LisaVisentin Science is in . Sack her ! Enough of this crap

LisaVisentin An education minister that doesn’t believe the science, yep that sounds about right - went straight from high school to study politics. Another career politician grifter.

LisaVisentin Sad, incompetence, totally irresponsible

LisaVisentin How the absolute hell is she an education minister if she can’t differentiate peer-reviewed evidence stemming back decades from a literal conspiracy theory and denial perpetuated by lobbyists?

LisaVisentin Mmm yes, breathing is a deeply philosophical act

LisaVisentin And why the debates go on; please extinguish the fires must be first priority

LisaVisentin Talking about religious discrimination is philosophical. Climate change making bushfires worse is fact

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin FFS

LisaVisentin She's charged with education? They should rename her portfolio minister for ignorance.

LisaVisentin An uneducated education minister. Just great.

LisaVisentin Education Minister you say?

LisaVisentin Debate, perhaps. But philosophical? And she’s the education minister?

LisaVisentin philAUSophy

LisaVisentin No-one can breathe in this air let alone have a debate - philosophical or any other kind. My kids deserve better than this and my taxes certainly do not support paying someone with these views. Can I have a refund?

LisaVisentin There will be lots of time left in the after life & universe to discuss 'philosophy' after the world burns down. GladysB LiberalNSW smitchellmlc JodiMcKayMP australianlabor

LisaVisentin The fact that somebody this stupidly ignorant is the Education Minister astounds me.

LisaVisentin Oh dear. Another numpty

LisaVisentin Not a debate. A denial.

LisaVisentin It’s not philosophical. It’s not a debate. Nor a belief. It’s “do you accept the science or not?” And, unfortunately, the LNP are not accepting of the science

LisaVisentin Education Minister

LisaVisentin

LisaVisentin Terrific This means we can think our way out of climate change impacts. Simpler and less expensive

LisaVisentin Jfc , no wonder education faltering in au !

LisaVisentin smitchellmlc If you're the Education Minister, and you cannot be educated on Climate Change, or its impacts, should you really be occupying that role? NSWpol Auspol

LisaVisentin Is that slightly more hopeful than a religious debate?

LisaVisentin So missy, you didn’t pay enough attention in my Science class to know the difference between one discipline and another. Harry Messel wept. Could throw his big blue book at you.

LisaVisentin Speculation is a poor form of politics. Stick to what you know....

LisaVisentin Actually she's right, it is a philosophical debate, from the branch known as natural philosophy (aka SCIENCE), and between a bunch of meteorologists, climatologists, and the like... And a bunch of Luddites Way to kick the can down the road EpicFail

LisaVisentin “Education Minister“ smitchellmlc appears to lack the education to know the differences between philosophy and hard science, and between debate and expedient denial.

LisaVisentin It's a scientific one...

LisaVisentin An Uneducated Education Min with zero logic?😂Like MSM/Leaders ogling the Ponzi$$ who think cutting off coal to starve the country of power to pay UN Billions Tax$Grab for a PROVEN Climate emergency SCAM while Aussies are driven into poverty. StopTheCon

LisaVisentin Air quality readings were off the charts in Sydney Who is to blame?: WB And why are we not using the RAAF?

LisaVisentin I can only find she studied politics & International relations at UNSW. But no degree listed in the Parliament page. That explains why it is a philosophical debate.

LisaVisentin The libs say they select ministers on merit what a joke

LisaVisentin Should politicians get off their asses and do something is a philosophical matter. Fires burning isn't.

LisaVisentin My God! How “Head in the sand” are they?

LisaVisentin It is a scientific matter, not a philosophical one.

LisaVisentin Well, it's scientific, and it's not a debate - it's a situation we are all in, experiencing now on a daily basis as we watch our kids play inside, our volunteers fight fires for weeks, our towns run out of water, famers despair. It's happening now. NSWfires NSWbushfires nswpol

LisaVisentin I guess Sarah is ignorant by choice. philosophicaldebate

LisaVisentin You don’t need a long neck to be a goose.

LisaVisentin Oh, it's philosophy, not science! And this is from our Education Minister? Hmm, may explain the plummeting ranking of Australian school students! 🙄 bushfires sydneysmoke climatechange

LisaVisentin Obviously she doesn’t reside in one of the 700 homes burnt by bushfire...is that how she offers sympathy characterising it as a philosophical argument

LisaVisentin Better titled Ignorance Minister.

MSMWatchdog2013 LisaVisentin Yes, there is never any danger this woman will be seen in the waiting room of MasterMind at the ABC. To be that dumb as to make that statement shows for certain that if brains were made of ink Sarah Mitchell would not have enough for a full stop. auspol

LisaVisentin Back to school for her. She clearly got a hospital pass last time.

LisaVisentin abcnews MaralynParker JodiMcKayMP Joe did probing interview of Matt Kean MP NSW Min for Enviro whose views it seems are at odds with that of the NSW Minister for Education who believes linking our fires to Climate Change is a philosophical debate!

LisaVisentin Clearly not bright enough to be a minister let alone one in charge of education. The only branch of philosophy involved is epistemology and the facts are clear.

LisaVisentin What? smitchellmlc. A philosophical debate is 'Does fire create or destroy?' This is Practical, physical science. Not Philosophy. resign nswpol auspol

LisaVisentin JodiMcKayMP MaralynParker Matt_KeanMP And she oversees the education of kids in NSW? Help!

LisaVisentin Seriously? There should be an expected level of intelligence before one becomes a minister. These ignorant liberal politicians should be the laughing stock of Australia

LisaVisentin patstokes Can you shed some light on this philosophical debate?

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 6. in AU

Australia Australia Latest News, Australia Australia Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Live: NSW Now: Smoke starts to settle, State Government links bushfires to climate changeMORNING BRIEFING: The Liberal Energy Minister speaks out about climate change, linking it to the state's catastrophic fires, and says there is no time to beat around the bush, while air quality is forecast to improve across NSW. DaveMyFace 98% of out of control fires in NSW are: In National Parks 80% are lit by humans 47% deliberately lit BREAKING! The ABC has found the root cause of all the terrible bushfires! A gutsy Matt Kean speaks out loud and says what is evident and a concern for most thinking Australians. Yet his leadership, on state and federal levels, are too bloody spineless to oppose the right wing climate change deniers of the “liberal” party. DISGUSTING
Source: abcnews - 🏆 5. / 83 Read more »